RothIRAHub

Understanding the illustrations

Same example.
Different state rules.

The state answer comes first. The dollar example is only a way to see how a rule can work under one set of facts.

Back to the state comparison

What the number means

State income tax with the conversion − state income tax without it = the example’s change.

Both amounts use the same person and circumstances. We apply relevant deductions, exemptions and income-tax credits separately in each case. Refundable credits are shown separately; a net amount is not automatically floored at zero.

The result is not a tax rate, a refund, a balance due, a recommendation to convert or a measure of all taxes on the transaction. Federal tax, county/city/district taxes, payroll tax, benefit changes, withholding and estimated payments are not included in the displayed amount.

Meet the fictional taxpayer

Year and age
2026; born June 15, 1981, and age 45 at conversion.
Filing and residence
Single U.S. citizen, full-year resident, not someone else’s dependent, with no dependents. Continuously resident in the state being compared throughout the account’s funding, the rollover and 2026; no other-state income or dual residence.
Income
$60,000 of ordinary W-2 wages, earned evenly during the year in an administrative support job at a private office-supply wholesaler. No other income, tips, overtime, special wage exclusions, federal income adjustments or elective pre-tax payroll deductions. Social Security and Medicare wages are also $60,000.
Conversion
On December 1, 2026, $20,000 moves directly from the owner’s ordinary Traditional IRA to the owner’s Roth IRA. All $20,000 is federally taxable; all stays in the Roth. There is no cash kept for spending, withholding or later distribution in the year.
Housing and health
Lives rent-free in another adult’s privately owned home, with no ownership or leasehold, rent, mortgage-interest or property-tax payment. The housing is neither government-subsidized nor an employer benefit. Has qualifying employer-paid health coverage all year, with no individual premiums, Marketplace assistance, medical deductions or HSA/FSA activity.
Deductions and other retirement activity
Federal standard deduction and applicable state standard deduction or equivalent; no itemizing. No other 2026 retirement distributions, rollovers or new IRA/workplace contributions, and no retirement exclusion already used that year.

Why the IRA’s history matters

Two accounts with the same balance can have different state treatment. The illustration therefore uses one specific history:

The example has no recoverable federal or state-taxed basis under this history. That conclusion requires the state’s own rules; federal basis alone cannot establish it. If your account contains money your state already taxed, do not apply the example amount to yourself.

What else stays fixed?

The taxpayer is not blind, disabled or a student and has no special military, public-service or tribal status. Ordinary employee Social Security and Medicare taxes are paid. There is no tuition expense or vehicle-loan interest. Residence and work locations are outside enterprise or equivalent employment-incentive zones. No county, city or district is selected.

Other activity and credit assumptions
  • No current or historical education, prepaid-tuition, 529 or ABLE funding, ownership or deductible attributes, including transferred interests, unused deductions or later payments attributed to an earlier year. No employer education-account contribution, match or reimbursement attributable to 2026, and no employer student-loan assistance or personal student-loan principal or interest payment.
  • No special-purpose state savings activity attributable to 2026, including medical, homebuyer, catastrophe, career, adoption, individual-development or county-development accounts. This includes deposits, matches, earnings, withdrawals, first-use rights, addbacks and recapture, even if paid later or by an employer or another person.
  • No health-care-sharing membership or payments; separate long-term-care premiums; screening or organ/tissue donation expenses; care, support or mileage expenses for another person; foster placement, stillbirth or adoption event; or disability-access expenditure for a dwelling.
  • No charitable gifts, political contributions, credit-eligible dues, qualifying licensing/training fees, volunteer-responder service, workforce-program eligibility, occupational credential, recruitment payment, qualifying educator or displaced-worker training expense, personal hiring-party contribution or qualifying energy-equipment purchase.
  • No business/pass-through activity, taxable investment gain or loss outside retirement accounts, gambling, credit-generating purchase, reforestation cost or assessed share, deductible casualty/disaster or other state loss, loss carryover/carryback, specialized credit carryforward, transferred/vested credit, first-use credit right or recapture-triggering prior claim.
  • No elective incentive/benefit program participation, food-assistance participation or incarceration during 2026. No election for receipt-based grocery relief. Generally available income-tax credits triggered by the stated facts still have to be considered.
  • No West Virginia motor-vehicle property-tax payment or legacy employee job-development assessment. These are not assumptions that the taxpayer has no vehicle or owes no other payroll assessment.
  • Ordinary wages use consistent cash-method reporting, without an earlier accrual estimate redetermined in 2026. No repayment of previously included income, prior-year refund, balance due or estimated-payment carryover used as a tax-base input. For an earlier federal audit or amendment, no additional tax has the later of its payment and final-determination dates in 2026.

We do not assume that prior-year tax liability was zero, that other household members are irrelevant, or that a mandatory payroll/local input is zero. If a complete state estimate needs an unsupported fact or calculation method, that estimate remains pending.

Why some examples are pending

The state’s conversion treatment can be supported even when a complete dollar estimate is not. An estimate also needs the applicable annual calculation method and all required deductions, credits and inputs. Where those are not fully verified, no estimate is shown.

A verified zero means no modeled change in state income tax under these facts. It does not mean the taxpayer owes no tax on wages, that federal conversion tax disappears, or that another account history gets the same result. Pending never means zero.

Dollar amounts follow the applicable state method and rounding rules, not a universal “conversion × top rate” shortcut. No inflation, investment-growth or future-return projection is part of this comparison.

Use your own records for your own decision

This is a 2026 full-year-resident comparison, not a moving-year allocation, inherited-account calculation, early cash withdrawal, direct workplace-plan conversion or SEP/SIMPLE conversion. It does not rank places to live.

For the federal distinction between conversion income and the early-distribution tax, see IRS Publication 590-A, “Converting From Any Traditional IRA Into a Roth IRA” and “Conversion methods” (2025 edition), and Treasury Regulation §1.408A-4, Q&A-7. State treatment is checked separately in the official state sources.

Check the conditions in your state’s row and consult a qualified professional for a decision involving your own return. Return to your state.